Beyond Labels

A 360° Discussion of Foreign, National and Local Policy Issues

Scott Miller

Nov. 18: Election Debrief

As a reminder, the library is closed on November 11 (Veteran’s Day). On November 18, we’ll take up the topic as agreed last week…the day before the election: an election debrief.

At the time, we thought we’d be discussing a flurry of litigation over who had won a close race for president—I guess that won’t take too much time. Instead, we can discuss some (or all) of the following:

Democrats

  • Why did Kamala Harris lose/what would have had to happen for her to win?
  • Have Democrats stopped listening to working class Americans as David Brooks suggests?
  • What lesson will Democrats take from the election overall:
    • Move firmly toward the working class (go to center)?
    • Double-down on progressive initiatives (go to left)?
    • “Steady as she goes” (perhaps this election was an anomaly and the overall platform is solid)?
  • To what degree will they support Republican initiatives on key voter issues (such as immigration)?

Republicans

  • To what degree will Trump’s actions be more moderate than his rhetoric?
  • To what degree will congressional Republicans push back on the Administration’s most aggressive initiatives?
  • How will Republicans manage high public expectations in light of the likely “tri-fecta” (Presidency plus a majority of both houses of Congress)? [Maybe a “quad-fecta” with a conservative majority on the Supreme Court as well.]
    • Will the Senate filibuster fall (or be constrained to narrower voting subjects)?

9/23/24: Ukraine (again) and Maybe China

For Monday, we’ll revisit U.S. support for Ukraine in the context of recent developments. In particular, we’ll start with the following two questions:

  • Should the U.S. authorize the use of Western-supplied weapons against military targets in Russian territory without limit? If not, what limits seem reasonable and appropriate under the circumstances?
  • Should the U.S. and its Western allies provide “frozen” Russian assets (bank deposits) to Ukraine to help that country finance its war effort?

If we move to China, we might discuss:

  • What lessons do we think China will take away from the U.S.’ support for Ukraine v. Russia in recent years? Are these the lessons we want them to “learn?” What, if anything, should we be doing differently vis-a-vis Ukraine to send China the signals we want?
  • China and the Philippines have been skirmishing at an increasing rate in the South China Sea over the past few months. What should U.S. policy be with respect to these skirmishes? Stand by and watch? Express displeasure through diplomatic means? Provide tangible non-military support to the Philippines? Provide military support (like by moving some Navy vessels into the “hot zone”)?

And I’m sure we’ll find more to discuss along the way. See you Monday.

  • Subscribe via Email

    Receive email notification of new posts/announcements about our weekly meeting.

    Join 244 other subscribers
  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments